An agent completes a purchase on one merchant site, then gets blocked on another for doing exactly what it was instructed to do. The fraud detection system can't distinguish authorized automation from credential stuffing—and that's the problem payment networks are now solving at infrastructure scale.
Payment networks don't build new protocols for emerging use cases—they build when production volume forces their hand. The 4,700% surge in AI-driven retail traffic isn't a forecast; it's what's already breaking merchant fraud detection systems. Visa's Trusted Agent Protocol and Mastercard's Agent Pay aren't preparing for future agent commerce—they're responding to what's breaking today.
Payment processors are treating agent authentication as infrastructure rather than edge case—the 4,700% surge in AI-driven retail traffic is forcing their hand.
Agents can complete purchases. The challenge is proving authorization when that agent attempts transactions across hundreds of merchant sites, each with different security architectures. Traditional authentication assumes human interaction: CVV codes, verification links, SMS prompts. When agents execute these sequences automatically, they trigger exactly the patterns fraud detection systems are designed to block.
We see this constantly: an agent successfully transacts on one merchant site, then gets blocked on another because that site's fraud detection interprets rapid, automated behavior as malicious. The agent is following instructions. Each merchant implements different security that treats automation as threat by default:
- 3D Secure flows requiring SMS verification with 60-second timeouts
- Device fingerprinting that flags new browser sessions
- Regional rate limits that vary by IP geolocation
There's no standard way to prove an agent is authorized rather than malicious.
Payment networks are solving this with cryptographic verification that proves agent identity without requiring human interaction. Visa's protocol uses HTTP Message Signatures to create tamper-proof, time-limited authorization. Mastercard's Agentic Tokens leverage existing tokenization infrastructure. Both address the same production reality: when agents transact at scale across fragmented merchant systems, you need authentication infrastructure that works reliably without triggering fraud blocks.
The technology matters less than what it signals: payment processors treating agent authentication as infrastructure rather than edge case. When Fiserv partners with Mastercard to deploy Agent Pay at scale, when PayPal launches agentic commerce services, they're signaling that proving agent authorization across thousands of merchant sites is moving from technical challenge to solved problem.
Authentication infrastructure that assumes agents will transact changes what's possible. A procurement analyst who manually checks 50 vendor sites weekly can now monitor 5,000 sites continuously—not because they're faster at clicking, but because authentication infrastructure no longer requires human verification at each transaction. The question shifts from "which vendors should we sample?" to "what patterns emerge across the entire supplier market?" Competitive intelligence teams can track pricing across complete markets rather than representative samples. Market operations teams can transact across hundreds of vendor sites without manual verification bottlenecks.
Teams building workflows around agent transactions can now assume authentication complexity is handled at the infrastructure layer. The bottleneck shifts from "can we prove authorization?" to "what do we do with transaction velocity?" Production infrastructure already reflects where agent-driven commerce is heading—payment networks are preparing for workflows that operate at internet speed across fragmented merchant systems.
Things to follow up on...
-
Stripe's Shared Payment Tokens: Stripe built a new payment primitive called Shared Payment Tokens that lets agents initiate payments using a buyer's permission without exposing credentials—programmable by design, scoped to specific businesses, and revocable at any time.
-
Dark web fraud evolution: Visa identified a 450% increase in dark web posts mentioning "AI Agent" over the past six months, with fraudsters automating scams and highlighting why authentication infrastructure development became urgent.
-
OpenAI's Instant Checkout rollout: ChatGPT's Instant Checkout launched with U.S. Etsy sellers automatically eligible and over a million Shopify merchants coming in Q4 2025—no integration required for merchants on these platforms.
-
Know Your Agent framework: The emerging Know Your Agent (KYA) principles build on established KYB and KYC models, providing robust identification and verification when agents register to reduce fraud and abuse risks.

